So many Israelis, particularly on the left of the political map (but not only) have considered for years that the aim of the Palestinian movement was one of nationalistic aims. In other words, the establishment of a Palestinian state. Thus, much of the thinking imposed similarities between the Zionistic aims and the Palestinian aims.
Haifa Diary
Haifa is on the "front line" in any action in the north but this blog looks at life in the shadow of danger to all of Israel
Thursday, May 15, 2025
The Oslo Accords Experiment is Dead
Wednesday, May 14, 2025
The West in Trouble - Does it Realise it?
Tuesday, May 13, 2025
The Yellow Parking Lot
(With thanks to my friend Forest Rain Marcia)
A yellow parking place, in a bustling parking lot, symbolically set aside for the hostages—until they all come home.
I don’t think people abroad comprehend how
all-consuming is the fact that there are hostages. In every moment, every
breath, they are with us.
The liberated hostages have told us about the
starvation, torture, and abuse. The lack of air and sun. We saw the physical
effects on them when they returned. Some of the effects.
I don’t think people abroad understand that the
hostages are a symbol of the horror and abuse we have suffered—and are still
suffering—from the Gazan invasion. They are not the totality of our suffering.
And rescuing them is not enough.
Even many Israelis don’t fully comprehend that.
We cannot wrap our minds, our hearts, around the
monstrous crimes that defiled our loved ones and destroyed the sanctity of our
homes. Homes destroyed. Families ripped apart. Soldiers killed and wounded.
Sons (and some daughters) crippled for life. Fathers who will never come home.
Countless people who saw soul-shattering things...
And the people around the world who deny,
justify, and celebrate October 7th.
It is easier not to see the entirety of our
pain. To deflect blame. To pretend that the return of the hostages would be
enough.
That it is possible to compromise with those who
promised to exterminate us.
That Israelis can return to their homes, when
their neighbors are the monsters who slaughtered their families.
That it is possible to live with neighbors who
we have taught can get anything they want—if they take Jews hostage—and what
they want is to destroy the Jewish State.
That there is any solution but removing the
threat.
Monday, May 12, 2025
Winning Battles, Losing Minds
By IRWIN J. (YITZCHAK) MANSDORF . Full Article at https://tinyurl.com/5bzzxxme
One of the most basic insights in behavioral psychology is
that people are wired to respond to immediate rewards even if those carry
long-term consequences. Whether it’s eating another slice of cake, smoking a
harmful cigarette, or running a red light, we tend to act when the benefit is
now and the price is later. If the reward feels good enough and the threat
seems distant enough, we take the risk.
This is not just human nature. It’s a weapon; one that Hamas has used masterfully in
its psychological war against Israel and the West over the past 18 months.
With the help of Iranian and Qatari backers,
Hamas has turned hostage diplomacy into a psychological trap. The emotional
appeal of bringing hostages home – a deeply human desire – has become the bait.
The cost? A stronger, bolder, more dangerous Hamas, just as ideologically
committed to Israel’s destruction as ever.
And the trap is working.
Every potential deal with Hamas carries a price. And the
terror organization ensures that the price is steep. Within Israel, a moral
rift is deepening. For some, particularly hostage families, nothing matters
more than bringing loved ones home. For others, the memory of October 7 and the
desire to ensure it never happens again means defeating Hamas, even at terrible
cost.
This is the heart of our moral dilemma: Two values – both
legitimate – that feel increasingly irreconcilable.
Hamas is exploiting this divide with precision. One day, it
offers a temporary hudna (“ceasefire”). The next, it releases a hostage video.
All the while, it plays the victim: children under rubble, hospitals without
power, shelters destroyed. The images are tragic – but they also serve a
purpose. The responsibility, they suggest, lies not with Hamas, but with
Israel.
Incredibly, many Israelis, who despise Hamas and all it
stands for, fall into this psychological trap. Instead of demanding that Hamas release the
hostages unconditionally, as international law requires, public anger
often turns inward, toward the Israeli government. It is a striking success of
Hamas’s psychologically asymmetric strategy.
The same is true in the West. There, the dominant narrative
is one of Israeli
oppression and “genocide” in Gaza. This narrative is a result of years
of emotional manipulation and moral confusion.
Headlines show starving children and suffering patients,
rarely acknowledging Hamas’s role in initiating the conflict or continuing to
hold innocent Israelis captive. The moral burden shifts to Israel, while the
terrorists evade accountability.
What does this all mean? First, we must take a more sober
view of the reality we’re in. The moral imperative to rescue living hostages is
real – but so is the government’s duty to protect its citizens from future
atrocities.
These are not easy choices. But they are not mutually
exclusive either. We must stop demonizing decisions we disagree with and start
appreciating the weight of the dilemma.
Second, we must recognize that Hamas is watching us,
learning about us, and playing us.
Militarily, we may be stronger. But on the psychological
battlefield, Hamas currently holds the emotional upper hand. That’s how it
continues to manipulate public opinion, both in Israel and in the West.
Tuesday, May 6, 2025
New Humanitarian Aid Plan for Gaza
Israel is preparing to implement a new humanitarian aid distribution system in southern Gaza designed to prevent Hamas from seizing the supplies, according to a report on Tuesday.
Distribution will be managed via a formal registration process overseen by vetted NGOs and American private contractors. A senior Israeli security official emphasized that the new system aims to eliminate Hamas’s ability to intercept or steal bulk shipments.
“Hamas will find it much harder to seize aid from Gazan families,” the official said. “It’s one thing to hijack a supply truck. It’s another to rob food directly from the hands of hungry civilians.”
The new mechanism comes amid heightened pressure from the United States and international community over humanitarian conditions in Gaza. On Monday, U.S. President Donald Trump acknowledged that “people are starving” in the Strip and pledged U.S. assistance, while sharply criticizing Hamas for seizing aid deliveries and “making it impossible” to help civilians in need.
Israeli officials believe the plan strikes the right balance—addressing civilian needs while denying Hamas the ability to weaponize humanitarian relief, according to the report.
Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar said Tuesday that he had briefed European Union High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas on the situation in Gaza, including the delivery of humanitarian aid to the coastal enclave.
“Hamas used the humanitarian aid that entered Gaza to feed its war machine,” Sa’ar wrote on X, warning that the war against the terrorist group would “continue forever” if such conditions persist.
“Therefore, Israel must change the way it facilitates the entrance of goods,” he added. “The international community—and any country interested in ensuring that aid reaches civilians rather than Hamas—must support Israel’s efforts, not obstruct them.”
From protest to duty: How Gaza war Recast the Israeli Reservist Ethos
As Israel expands its Gaza campaign, reservists who once questioned the system now report for duty.
For the full report click here.
Less than two years ago, some Israeli reservists threatened
to put down their rifles. They marched in Tel Aviv, signed letters of protest,
and warned that serving under a government dismantling the country’s democratic
foundations would be a betrayal of their values.
Today, many of those same reservists are packing bags and
crossing back into Gaza.
“I’ve been called up three times already,” says Liel
Friedmann, a 38-year-old infantry reservist from Tel Aviv. “People ask, ‘Why
are you going again?’ But this isn’t a social club. There’s no one else. That’s
the truth.”
Friedmann, who spoke just hours before
deployment, reflects a broader transformation among segments of Israeli society
once aligned with protest. His voice—anxious but resolved—embodies the fatigue
of war and the burden of necessity.
“I try not to think too much about civilian life when I’m
called,” he says. “The second round, a few months ago, felt pointless. It was
like we were just stretching the war out. But now it feels more focused, like
there’s a goal.”
That goal—at least in the eyes of Israel’s military
establishment and right-leaning security circles—is the complete dismantling of
Hamas and the return of 59 hostages still believed to be held in Gaza. To
achieve that, the government is now calling up tens of thousands of reservists
in what may be the most extensive reserve mobilization since October.
According to Lt. Col. (res.) Yaron Buskila,
secretary-general of the Israel Defense and Security Forum, this call-up is not
a matter of policy—it’s a matter of survival.
“This is not a choice. It’s a necessity,” “There is no way to defeat Hamas or to bring the hostages home without
reserve forces. Negotiations could drag on for years—and that would only
endanger the hostages further.”
As tens of thousands of Israelis report for duty once again,
the picture is complex. Loyalty to the country does not mean loyalty to its
leaders. For some, the uniform is a burden. For others, it’s a line of
defense—for their families, for democracy, and for the right to keep fighting
for both.
The IDF Current Goals
Brigadier General (Res.) Amir Avivi says the IDF must put pressure on the
terror organization to release the hostages
The IDF is
consistently pursuing three main goals, according to Brigadier General (Res.)
Amir Avivi of IDSF, the Israel Defense and Security Forum
He told a local News channel that :-
the first goal is improving the defense of the towns along the Gaza Strip.
“We have to bring back people to the kibbutzim that are really close to the border,” he said. “In order to do that, we need to push Hamas west toward the sea and secure the area.”
The second goal is to put pressure on the terror organization to release the hostages
“It’s crystal clear that Hamas is not pressured enough. They need to be pressured more in order to bring them to the point where they are willing to do a hostage deal—without Israel needing to give up its goals of war, without giving up the mission of eradicating Hamas,” Avivi said.
Finally, the third goal is to destroy Hamas’s rule in Gaza. To that end, the government have announced that more troops are being called to battle.